Skip to content
As seen on TV
Free next day delivery orders over £45
Mudfoods logo

Most Popular Pie Fillings

When it comes to choosing a pie, the options are endless. There are so many different mouth-watering flavours to choose from that you really are spoilt for choice! There is nothing more satisfying and comforting than tucking into a pie, whether as a quick bite on the go or sitting down to a proper pie-based dinner with piping hot gravy and delicious, perfectly matched side dishes. A hot pie, where a delightful, flavoursome filling is encased in a perfectly cooked melt-in-your-mouth, butter-rich pastry, is just the thing to keep us feeling warm and full - particularly on these colder autumnal days.

People have been eating pies for hundreds of years, and in that time, we've managed to perfect the fillings so that there really is something for everyone to enjoy. So whether you are a traditionalist or an adventurer, a meat-lover or vegetarian, want something light and fresh, or hearty and sumptuous - we've got the perfect pie for you.

To get your mouth watering and stomach rumbling, let's take a look at some of the most popular fillings for pies to date.

Popular pie fillings for all taste buds!

Steak and Kidney

Why mess with perfection? Steak and kidney pies have been eaten since the 1600s. It's a classic comfort food option and is a staple on many British pub menus. Our version is prepared with the finest quality, locally sourced organic steak, combined with ox kidney and simmered gently in red wine to create a rich gravy. All of this is encased in our signature shortcrust pastry making for a hearty, savoury mouthful every time you bite.

Cheese and Onion

You can't go wrong with a classic cheese and onion pie. This pie filling is perfect for a quick lunch or dressed up with some delicious side dishes to make an impressive evening meal. Buttery pastry and tangy cheese are a match made in heaven. We pack ours with mature cheddar, Red Leicester and add a glug of locally-sourced cider and a sprinkling of chives - no wonder it achieved a silver medal at the British Pie Awards 2021.

Chicken and Mushroom

The combination of sweet, succulent chicken and earthy mushrooms has been a favourite of many a Briton over the years. When you add a few cheeky extras, such as a creamy white wine sauce, and then encase the whole lot in a gorgeous butter-rich pastry, you know you are onto a winner.

Chip Shop Chicken Curry

British people love a good curry, and they love a good pie. So when you combine the two as we did with our award-winning chip shop chicken curry pie you know that it's going to be a popular choice! Generous chunks of British free-range chicken lovingly prepared in a sweet, mild curry sauce make this pie one of the best around.

Squash, Spinach and Feta Pie

Sometimes we all like to try something a little different, and in recent years we've noticed that less traditional pie filling flavours are starting to increase in popularity. For vegetarians and vegans, the range of pie options used to be pretty small. Now there are plenty of great flavours and fillings to choose from. Soft sweet squash, tangy crumbly feta cheese and fresh spinach make for a tastebud tantalising combination that's going to impress vegans, vegetarians, and meat-eaters alike. For our version, we've added some sweet and mild chilli and tomato sauce and created our vegan pastry using Umami and soya milk to ensure crisp, flaky perfection- just as it should be.

Perfect Pies For Everyone!

At Mud Foods, we firmly believe that no matter what kinds of flavours you love, you'll find a pie that brings a smile to your face here. So if you are looking for pies made with passion by those who love them, why not take a look at our full range of pies and choose your perfect pie today?

Join the Mud Club

If you’d like to hear about our latest offers and keep in touch with news from the pie world, just sign up here for the Mud Club newsletter. Easy as pie!

Get 10% off your first order and a chance to win free pies in our monthly draw!“I was absolutely surprised, having just signed up for your online newsletter, to hear that I had won a dozen pies in your monthly draw.  It almost feels like winning the Lottery, but hopefully that’s next month!!!”

Ian, Midhurst

If you ever want to step back from the pie party, simply click the unsubscribe link. For all the fine print, check out our Privacy Policy & Terms.

Sign up
Pies by email

Follow us

Mudfoods logo

Contact us

GU29 9RE
Phone: 01730 815435
Or email us via our form



Food Hygiene rating - 5 - Very Good
safe and local supplier approved
Sign up

Sign up to the Mud Club for special offers and a chance to win free pies in our monthly draw!

Copyright © 2024. All rights reserved. | Web design by Rococo Digital

American Express
Apple Pay
Diners Club
Google Pay
Shop Pay